J. Frances Hays, of New Castle, PA, came to Transylvania County for health reasons in 1890. He founded the Toxaway Company in 1896 which was responsible for the fabulous resorts for which the area is remembered: Franklin Hotel, Fairfield Inn; Sapphire Inn, The Lodge, and the beautiful Toxaway Inn pictured above.
 
The dream of J. Frances Hayes was fulfilled when the construction of a lake was completed, and the Toxaway Inn was ready for occupancy in the western North Carolina mountains in 1903.
 
The Toxaway Inn was a spectacular structure, five stories high, surrounded by a wide veranda. There were over 500 rooms, each with a view of the lake and mountain scenery. The ultra conveniences of 1903 included a hydraulic generating plant built below the dam to furnish electricity for the inn and adjoining facilities; rooms paneled with native wood such as oak, chestnut, walnut or cherry, all having been cut from the Toxaway property; immense fireplaces of glazed green and white tile with great mantles surmounted by oval, gold rimmed plate glass mirrors; steam heat; elevators; refrigerating machinery; electric lighting; the latest in baths; long distance telephones and Western Union.
 
Mr. Hayes used all these modern conveniences in his national advertising to attract the elite clientele from all over the world. Such people as the Fords, Vanderbilts, Firestones, Rockefellers, Edisons, Reynolds, Dukes, Wanamakers and the Nunnallys patronized it. These guests were never without entertainment. A first class orchestra played and there was dancing in the beautifully chandeliered ballroom. Daily concerts were presented for the pleasure of the guests. The inn featured billiard rooms, bowling alleys, a pool and a bar. Outdoor activities included boating, swimming, fishing, golf, tennis, horseback riding and hunting.
 
In August, 1916, a hurricane came ashore in the Gulf of Mexico, moved up the Mississippi Valley and combined with a smaller storm to dump additional water on an already saturated North Carolina. The early dam collapsed under the tremendous pressure and with the removal of this main attraction "Lake Toxaway", the Toxaway Inn could not keep up its image as the Little Switzerland of America. This was the end of elegance and entertainment on a grand scale. To our sorrow, the dismantling of the inn began in 1947.
 
In the late 50's David and Bertha Cosby bought the property for a music camp and a real estate venture. In 1960 the bulk of the property was then purchased by a group of investors, headed by R. D. Heinitsh, Sr., from Columbia, SC. The recreation of the dam and refilling of the lake brought excitement to Transylvania County and; as stated by the Transylvania Times, July 29, 1965, "Somehow, one can't help but draw a comparison between Lake Toxaway and the enchantment of Sleeping Beauty. The lakefront slept without water for 45 years; and now once again the lake is indeed a beauty."